Huriwa Logo

Huriwa Logo

Thursday, 12 September 2013

FISCAL NOISE COMMISSION By Emmanuel Onwubiko



Nigeria is the giant of Africa in name, no doubt. But in action, Nigeria is more or less like a lame duck. For well over five decades, crude oil and other rich mineral resources have been discovered and exploited in huge commercial quantities and the nation’s large population still battle with mass poverty and insecurity, no thanks to the rich presence in the polity of well endowed criminal elements who have taken the commanding lead in the various segments of Nigeria’s political spectrum thereby institutionalizing corruption and fiscal indiscipline.
In the last two decades, corruption has become the single largest contributor to Nigeria’s underdevelopment, infrastructure deficits and mass poverty even as successive governments over the years have failed to build viable regulatory and enforcement institutions to check the unprecedented spread of these social vices of corruption, bribery and outright theft of public resources by top government officials at all levels beginning from the federal down to the rural government settings.
One of the ways worked out by the previous government of Chief Olusegun Obasanjo to stem the high tide of corruption was the setting up of fiscal Responsibility Commission among few other anti-graft institutions. The formation of these anti-graft agencies derived inspiration basically from section 15[5] of the Nigerian Constitution of 1999[as amended] which frowns against corruption and abuse of power and consequently obliges all segments of the Nigerian society to eradicate corruption.
The fiscal Responsibility Commission was one of the logical products of the resolve of corporate Nigeria to strangulate corruption and fiscal indiscipline that constitute serious cog in the wheel of progress of Nigeria. Fiscal responsibility commission on paper has the vision of ensuring the enthronement of a regime of prudent, ethical and effective management of public monies and resources across all tiers of government.
The Fiscal responsibility commission’s mission on paper is to reform the management of Nigeria’s public finances through regular monitoring of government financial activities, uncompromising investigation and public reporting backed by a firm commitment to enforcement under the rule of law.
The Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2007 saddled the body with the functions of among others; to monitor and enforce the provisions of the Act and by so doing, promote economic objectives contained in section 16 of the Nigerian Constitutions; and to disseminate such standard practices including international good practices that will result in greater efficiency in the allocation and management of public expenditure, revenue collection, debt control and transparency in Fiscal matters.
It was established by the fiscal Responsibility Act of 2007 as an independent agency in the performance of its core functions.
But since 2007 when it became operational, it is a notorious fact that fiscal indiscipline and abuses of the provisions of the fiscal responsibility law have become widespread just as this agency saddled with these onerous tasks of tackling the challenges of corruption has conveniently gone to sleep and become a toothless bull dog. Total lack of transparency now characterizes the handling of public fund by all sections of public officials including bureaucrats in the various federal ministries.
Like few other dysfunctional anti-graft institutions, the fiscal responsibility commission has consistently become very irresponsible and has become only responsible in creating media noise without ever adopting effective measures to name, shame, prosecute and punish offenders. Coupled with the fact that the fiscal commission is run like a secret society devoid of transparent partnership of credible civil society groups, this agency of government which cost tax payers so much resources to maintain has become a dysfunctional contraption and the only way to save the country from tolerating a perfectly incompetent and unworkable contraption is to introduce radical reforms of the administration of this near-moribund fiscal responsibility commission.
By law, the fiscal Responsibility Commission ought to be composed of representatives of broad spectrum of schools of thought including the civil society groups engaged in causes relating to probity, transparency and governance, the selection process of the hierarchy of this agency has become opaque and muddled up in partisan politics.
A major imperfection of the fiscal responsibility body is the total disregard of the freedom of information Act of 2011 even when the constitution in section 15(5) provides that; “The state shall abolish all corrupt practices and abuse of power.”
Recently, the fiscal responsibility commission denied the request under freedom of information Act of 2011 instituted by HUMAN RIGHTS WRITERS’ ASSOCIATION OF NIGERIA to compel the boss of that agency to name and shame a top public office holder he accused in a newspaper interview (without disclosing identity) of large scale corruption.
The human rights group had requested that the chairman of the fiscal commission disclose the identity of a top federal government official that was indicted of cornering to himself huge government revenue in foreign denominations of a particular agency but the fiscal responsibility chairman denied the Human Rights Writers’ Association of Nigeria that germane request supported by section 1 of the freedom of information Act.
The chairman of the fiscal Responsibility Commission had in an interview published on August 6th 2013 by Daily Trust accused the unnamed government official of stealing millions of dollars belonging to the federal government.
The human rights group had innocuously demanded that the fiscal commission give Nigerians the name of the official since the money stolen rightly belonged to the people of Nigeria but as is the practice with the dysfunctional state of affairs of most federal government agencies which still operate the corruption – friendly principle of “say no evil even when you see evil happening”, it failed to respond to this patriotic request.
Hiding under the nebulous provision of the fiscal responsibility Act, the agency said it will not honour the freedom of information request because disclosing the name of the indicted official will harm the ongoing investigation.          
“I can confirm to you that the Fiscal Responsibility Commission will withhold the information you have requested because we consider that the exemptions under the following section of the F.O.I. Act, 2011 apply to your request. They are section 14(1)(e) and Section 12(1)(a),(i),(ii),(iii),(iv),(vi);(4)”
“We appreciate that this will be a considerable disappointment to you and would herein endeavour to explain to you why we reached the decision to refuse your request as outlined above, “the fiscal commission gladly announced to the Human Rights Writers’ Association of Nigeria.
Annoyingly, few days after refusing to name and shame a public official indicted by it for large scale fraud, the same fiscal responsibility commission was quoted in the Nigerian media (The Guardian, Friday September 6th 2013, pg. 1) as raising alarm over the recklessness of states in Nigeria to over borrow.
The fiscal responsibility commission also regretted that only five states out of the 36 states in Nigeria have embraced the Fiscal Responsibility Act in the last six years of its existence.
But I have this piece of news for this noisy commission and that is to tell the officials to desist from disturbing our peace with irrelevant noise since the hierarchy cannot provide the required leadership qualities for other federating units to embrace the law.
What do you expect from the body when the head is rotten?  “Physician, heal thyself,” [courtesy of the Holy Bible].
The officials of the Nigeria’s fiscal responsibility commission should please buy a copy of the well researched leadership book from the prestigious Harvard Business School titled; “Hand Book of leadership theory and practice.”         
In the section one of this book where the versatile authors analytically highlighted the all important issue of “the impact of leadership: performance and meaning,” whereby they stated rightly thus; “… Put simply, if leadership does not directly impact or significantly impact organizational performance, then leadership does not matter to organizational life.”
To tackle the widespread cases of fiscal indiscipline, corruption and inefficiency in the running of government business, agencies like the fiscal responsibility commission must say no to the business-as-usual tendency of covering up for corrupt officials and become vibrant anti-graft institutions.


*          Emmanuel Onwubiko, Head, HUMAN RIGHTS WRITERS’ ASSOCIATION OF NIGERIA; blogs@www.huriwa.blogspot.com. http://www.huriwa.org/; 

12/9/2013

Tuesday, 13 August 2013

DEBATE ON ELECTRICITY TARIFF By Emmanuel Onwubiko



Miss. Asabe Abdulsallami [names not real] is a 26 year old graduate of industrial chemistry from one of the upscale privately run Universities owned by one of the very flourishing Pentecostal Churches.  She recently graduated in flying colors and served in one of the most high profile federal government agencies and upon completion of her compulsory one year national service with the National Youth service Corp [NYSC] she was retained on merit as a full time staff even as she is now staying in a two -bed room apartment in Maitama after her very successful industrialist father rented the highly expensive accommodation for her. 

Although surrounded by opulence, the beautiful Miss. Asabe has a big problem staring her in her innocent eyes since she still has a major infrastructural crisis in her residence to contend with which has to do with the general situation of epileptic electricity power supply, a problem that afflicts all segments of the society but severely faced by the very poor who reside in the many derelict and grossly under-developed rural areas across the country. 

One day this writer engaged her in a meaningful dialogue regarding the state of poor electricity supply and she lamented that although she has seen little improvement in the supply of electricity in Abuja but the issue of exorbitant tariff charged for this services by the Distribution Services Companies known now in the common parlance of DISCO has become a fundamental burden to the generality of Nigerians.

She is of the opinion which most Nigerians share that it will be more logical for the nation's policy makers to improve the quality and scope of distribution of electricity power in all parts of the Country before playing around with the idea of increasing the tariff charged.  Asabe told me in philosophical terms that the argument by the National Electricity Regulatory Commission [NERC] that increasing the tariff to be charged for electricity supply is key to attracting the much needed foreign investments in the electricity sector amounted to 'putting the cart before the horse' or to similarly argue that 'the egg comes before the chicken'.  

I have therefore decided to intervene in this raging debate to present all sides of the arguments for purposes of clarity and for Nigerians to decide what is best for us as a nation that has perpetually remained in total electricity darkness while other nations even in Africa [South Africa] have gone far.  

The Chairman of NERC, the urbane and US -trained lawyer Dr. Sam Amadi has demonstrated more than enough evidence as one public officer who is constantly on the side of the people and who believes that only the best decisions that serve the public interest should be implemented.

In the next couple of weeks I will dedicate my column to this debate. I am aware that the Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission – NERC has issued a 14-day ultimatum to electricity distribution companies (DISCOs) that are in violation of its Order to submit a list of all customers who paid for meters since January 2011, and commence metering them with immediate effect.

“Any DISCO that does not comply with this new directive will be barred from collecting the new electricity tariff”, Chairman/CEO NERC - Dr. Sam Amadi says.
In a letter dated 19th July, the Commission expressed its utter dismay that all DISCOs have been in complete violation of the order as it relates to customers who have made payments within the given time frame, and have not been identified for immediate metering.   
“NERC views this conduct as totally unresponsive, and undermining the effort of the reform”.

Recall that NERC had earlier in the year issued an Order on CAPMI – Credited Advance Payment for Metering Implementation. CAPMI was a response by the regulator to address the lingering issue of non-issuance of meters by the electricity companies. CAPMI allows for any interested and willing customer to advance money to their electricity distribution company and in return will be given electricity credit until the cost of the meter has been recovered by the customer.

The CAPMI Order, amongst other things, stipulated that all distribution companies forward to NERC data of all customers who paid for meters but had not been supplied.

It can be recalled that in 2011, a N2.9billion metering intervention fund was made available to the companies with a view to closing the unacceptable metering gap. One year after, no appreciable progress was made by the companies, and this compelled NERC to demand for performance reports from the DISCOs. Eight of the twelve DISCOs submitted reports that fell far short of the requirements of NERC. The rest did not submit any report of how they spent the money.

Even the most hardened opponent of this government will agree that NERC has started a radical revolution that is unprecedented in the political annals of Nigeria.

The DISCOs were further warned that failure to comply with the 14-day ultimatum would also compel the Commission to institute enforcement procedures that may result in the removal of a Chief Executive Officer of an electricity distribution company.

This is indeed cheering to the public ear.


*          Emmanuel Onwubiko writes from Human Rights Writers Association of Nigeria; Abuja. http://www.huriwa.blogspot.com/; http://www.huriwa.org/.



13/8/2013